Part one (1 page)
Summary of Aristotle′s Ethics: nicoamchean ethics
Part two (1 page)
Summary of Nietzsche: genealogy of morals, and the madman
Part three (1 page)
Summary of McIntyre “after virtue reading”
Part four (1 page)
Define ethical issue
What constitutes an issue to be an ethical issue
Give an example
Part five(1 page)
Compare and contrast how Aristotle and Nietzsche would address the ethical issue of your paper. Show in detail how they would respond and explain why (25pts).
a. The most important part is that you substantiate what you think their evaluations would be with reasons (use quotes from the readings, class notes, etc.)
2. Conclude your paper with an assessment of which philosopher wins.Establish the criteria for victory, that means, establish what criteria you think should be used to compare the two ethical theories. Here you are doing the work to answer McIntyre’s question: “But which ought we to choose? And how ought we to choose?” (After Virtue p. 118).
To do this explain why one is better than the other. Support your view with reasons. It is here that you should probably find the C.S. Lewis readings most helpful